Skip to content Skip to footer

From No-Hit to No Quit: Cavaliers Rally Past Cuyahoga 8-6

Softball team in gray uniforms gathers in a circle on a turf field near home plate, raising hands and high-fiving around a helmeted player wearing a “JC” logo. A catcher stands at left holding gear, while other players with visible numbers (including 1, 12, 5, and 26) face inward. Spectators sit behind a chain-link backstop fence in the background under bright daylight.
JCCC softball team celebrates after scoring a key run.

DUNCAN, S.C. — One day after being held hitless on the biggest stage of the season, Johnson County delivered a response that defined its resilience.

Facing elimination in the NJCAA Division II World Series, the Cavaliers rallied from a late deficit and erupted for five runs in the bottom of the sixth inning, stunning Cuyahoga Community College 8-6 Thursday morning at Tyger River Park to keep their season alive.

Johnson County (38-12) shook off the frustration of its first-round no-hitter loss and instead authored one of its most dramatic comebacks of the year—leaning on timely hitting, patience at the plate and lockdown pitching when it mattered most.

Trailing 6-3 entering the sixth, the Cavaliers flipped the game in a matter of minutes.

Katie Courter sparked the rally, while Mariah Herrera and Alaryce Millard helped keep the line moving as Johnson County began to chip away. Makenzie Yoder drove in a run, and Katie Kolarik delivered in a big moment with a two-RBI effort. The biggest swing came from Kennedy Glassford, whose three RBI—including a home run—provided the offensive jolt the Cavaliers had been searching for all tournament long.

By the time the inning ended, Johnson County had turned a three-run deficit into an 8-6 lead—its first advantage since early in the game.

The comeback overshadowed a fast start by Cuyahoga (34-8), which jumped out to a 3-0 lead in the first inning and built a 5-0 cushion through three innings. The Challengers added another run later, capitalizing on early opportunities while keeping Johnson County's offense quiet outside of a three-run burst in the third.

But unlike the opening round, when the Cavaliers failed to register a hit, this time they refused to stay silent. Johnson County collected nine hits and worked three walks, steadily wearing down the Cuyahoga pitching staff before delivering the decisive sixth-inning surge.  

Inside the circle, the Cavaliers also found the right formula after a rocky start.

Starter Elsa Carrillo battled through three innings, allowing five runs—though none were earned—before giving way to Kyleigh Whitehurst. Whitehurst proved to be the stabilizing force Johnson County needed, holding Cuyahoga to just two hits and one run across the final four innings to earn the victory.

With the lead in hand in the seventh, Whitehurst went back out and closed the door, retiring the final hitters to seal the comeback and send the Cavaliers into celebration.

Cuyahoga, which finished with five hits, had built its lead behind timely production from players like Isabelle Kepple and Katelyn Smith, but could not withstand Johnson County's late push.

For Johnson County, the win wasn't just about survival—it was a statement.

After the disappointment of being no-hit a day earlier, the Cavaliers responded with poise and persistence, showing the offensive depth and fight that carried them to the national tournament in the first place.

Now, with renewed energy and momentum, Johnson County remains alive in the bracket, one step at a time, refusing to let its season end quietly.